Mot vai suy ngh ve

"D An Chnh Tr Dan Chu a Nguyen 1996, Th Thach va Hy Vong" cua Thong Luan


Hu Nguyen

May thang gan ay, ong Nguyen Gia Kieng va nhom Thong Luan a chophat hanh tai My va Chau Au mot tap tai lieu nhan e "D An ChnhTr Dan Chu a Nguyen 1996, Th Thach va Hy Vong". Tai Uc, bao VietLuan cung a gii thieu, ang tai va phan phoi tap tai lieu cho nhngai yeu cau qua Email hoac lien lac thang vi toa soan.
Ban "D an" day tren di 90 trang c chia lam 9 phan trongo phan ba, "Nhng niem tin nen tang", va phan bon, "Nhngnh hng ln", la hai phan chnh yeu, chiem ti non na ban"D an". Noi dung chnh yeu cua ban "D an" la a ranhng quan iem cung phng thc "hoa hp hoa giai" e dan chuhoa Viet Nam theo con ng ma nhom Thong Luan goi la "dan chu anguyen".
Tren danh ngha, viec lam cua ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan laang quy, ang tran trong. Nhng tren thc te, sau khi oc li giithieu ang tren bao Viet Luan va nghien cu tap tai lieu, nhat la khithay trong ban "D an" co cau, "Dan chu a nguyen khong nhngla chon la hien nhien cho Viet Nam ma con la hng i tat yeu cualoai ngi tien bo", toi thay co nhieu iem khong tan ong bencanh mot so iem tan ong oi vi ban "D an". o la ly do khientoi viet bai viet na
V bai viet cua toi tng oi dai ma pham vi trang bao co han nentrc het toi xin c trnh bay ve nhng iem khong tan ong. Trongso bao thang nay toi viet ve ba iem khong tan ong: Th nhat lakhong tan ong cach dung t "dan chu a nguyen" trong ban"D an". Th hai la nhng suy ngh cua toi ve li gii thieuban "D an" cua Thong Luan. Th ba la mot vai cam tng cuatoi sau khi oc nhng li nhan xet ban "D an" cua cac v khoabang c Thong Luan vien dan. Trong nhng so ti, toi se noi lennhng bat ong oi vi noi dung cua ban "D an" trc khi viet venhng iem tan ong.
Trc khi vao bai toi cung xin c noi ro mot so iem. Th nhat,trong bai viet, tat ca nhng t "D an" viet hoa trong ngoackep eu co ngha ban "D an chnh tr a nguyen 1996, Th Thach vaHy Vong" cua Thong Luan; Th hai, mac du thay bao ch xa nay vangoi "nhom Thong Luan", t "nhom" khong chay lam, nhng v khong biet dung t nao khac cho ung nen oi chotranh khong c, toi phai gi nguyen. Th ba, ten "ong Kieng"va "nhom Thong Luan" du co mot so cho ch c neu mot tronghai, nhng mong ban oc hieu ngi viet co y neu ca ha
* * *

DAN CHU A NGUYEN CO PHAI LA DAN CHU HAY KHONG?
Trong ban "D an" t "dan chu a nguyen" clap i lap lai nhieu lan v ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan coi ola mot phat minh oc ao v no "khong nhng la chon la hien nhiencho Viet Nam ma con la hng i tat yeu cua loai ngi tien bo".(!!)Vay dan chu a nguyen la g? Dan chu a nguyen co phai la dan chuhay khong? Tra li cau hoi nay, ban "D an" a co mot caunguyen van nh sau: "Dan chu a nguyen la dan chu nhng khongphai dan chu nao cung la dan chu a nguyen".
Thoat nghe lap luan tren ta thay qua hu ly, hu ly en o phai phc No cung hu ly nh loi lap luan, "con nga bach la con nganhng khong phai con nga nao cung la con nga bach". T loi lapluan thuan ao tng xng nh vay, ta co the a ra ca ngan lap luanhu ly mot cach tc ci khac nh, "co gai xinh ep la ngi nhngkhong phai ngi nao cung la co gai xinh ep"; "Con ga mai la con ganhng khong phai con ga nao cung la ga mai"...
D nhien, khi oc mot lo nhng lap luan thuan ao tren, nhieu vse cho rang nhng lap luan o nghe th hp ly nhng ai ma lai lapluan khung khung, mat mat nh vay bao gi? Cam ngh o cua quy vcung la cam ngh chung cua tat ca nhng ngi bnh thng neu phaithay mot ngi bat bnh thng toi ngay c lam nham mot ieu xa nhtrai at va ai ai cung biet, "Nc soi la nc nhng khong phainc nao cung la nc soi".
May man nhom Thong Luan va ong Kieng khong phai la nhng ngi khungkhung mat mat bat bnh thng nh nhieu ngi thoat au lo nga Lamot tap hp bao gom "hn mot tram nha tr thc, khoa bang" noitieng trong va ngoai nc cung ban cai, tranh luan ca nam tri thchac chan nhom Thong Luan phai thong thai, gioi giang gap ba chuc ongGia Cat la t.
Nhng neu ho a khong khung khung mat mat th tai sao ho lai a raloi lap luan ky cuc nh vay
e co the tra li cau hoi nay xin quy oc gia oc ky lai cau lap luancua nhom Thong Luan: "Dan chu a nguyen la dan chu nhng khongphai dan chu nao cung la dan chu a nguyen". oc roi quy v sethay loi lap luan cua ho khong n gian ngay ngo ma la mot loi nguybien kha khon ngoan nham dan nhan hieu dan chu len cai goi la "danchu a nguyen" ho va mi nan. Mot khi ta de dai chap nhan loi nguybien o, ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan se dat ta i en chap nhan quaniem "hoa hp hoa giai" tng bc vi cong san ma ho a neutrong ban "D an".
ay ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan a co tnh nguy bien ngay tmenh e au tien khi ho cho rang "dan chu a nguyen la dan chu".S thc, dan chu a nguyen khong the nao la dan chu va vnh vienkhong bao gi ta chap nhan tnh trang lon song ch ngha nh vay cuaThong Luan. Nen nh, t ban than t "dan chu" a goi ghem qua roy ngha "dan lam chu". Nh the la qua u. Vay th tai sao nhomThong Luan phai e ra cum t "dan chu nhat nguyen" e goi cheo cong san VN hien nay va "dan chu a nguyen" e ch che oma ho cho la ly tng trong tng la Ban than ca hai cum t nay eut mau thuan v thc te khong bao gi co mot the che chnh tr a "danlam chu" lai con "nhat nguyen" chap nhan s hien hu cua motang oc tai chuyen che hoac "a nguyen" a au che.
Thiet ngh, viec nhom Thong Luan nan ra nhng thuat t quanh hai ch"dan chu" nh "dan chu nhat nguyen", "dan chu phaptr", "dan chu a nguyen"... chang qua ch la cach nguybien e trc t la mnh, sau bp thien ha tren bc ng "hoahp, hoa giai" vi cong san nham thoa man tham vong quyen lcchnh tr cho phe nhom va ca nhan ma tho
Qua viec hoi han mot so v than hao, nhan s va khoa bang trong congong, toi c biet trong ngon ng chnh tr the gii xa nay khongco t nao goi la "dan chu a nguyen" hay "dan chu nhatnguyen" mac du trong Anh ng co ca 150 t mo ta nhng the che chnhtr khac nhau
e co the thay ro loi nguy bien cua nhom Thong Luan, toi xin phep cban rong mot chut ve y ngha cua t "dan chu" trong lch s.T "dan chu" c dch rat sat ngha t ch"democracy", ngha la quyen lc thuoc gii bnh dan. Thuat tchnh tr nay c tao thanh t hai tieng goc Hy Lap la"demos" ngha la "gii bnh dan"; va "kratia" nghala "sc manh, quyen lc".
Hnh thai chnh tr "quyen lc thuoc gii bnh dan" c hnhthanh vao the ky th 5 trc Cong Nguyen, oi choi vi hnh thai"quyen lc trong tay thanh phan quy toc" menh danh laaristocrac Thi o, democracy la mot trong sau the thc chnh trc triet gia Aristotle e cap. Mac du luc o co mot so th quoc taiHy Lap ap dung the thc chnh tr dan chu, thc te, phu n,ngi no le va ngoai nhan van khong c quyen bo phieu
Ngoai cach ghep vi v ng "cracy", tieng Anh con ghep vi vng "archy", (cung goc Hy Lap) ngha la "lanh ao", e taothem nhieu t mi e ch cac hnh thai chnh tr khac nhau Qua hailoi tiep v ng tren, mot loat t c tao thanh nh autocracy,monocracy: chuyen che, oc tai, quyen lc chnh phu nam trong tay motngi; biarchy, diarchy, duarchy: lng au che, quyen lc chnh phunam trong tay hai ngi; triarchy: tam au che, quyen lc chnh trnam trong tay ba ngi; tetradarchy, tetrarchy: t au che, quyen lcchnh phu nam trong tay bon ngi; pentarchy: ngu au che, quyen lcchnh phu nam trong tay nam ngi; heptarchy: that au che, quyen lcchnh phu nam trong tay bay ngi; octarchy: bat au che, quyen lcchnh phu nam trong tay tam ngi; decarchy, decadarchy: thap auche, quyen lc nam trong tay mi ngi; dodecarchy: thap nh che,quyen lc nam trong tay mi hai ngi; hecatontarchy: bach au che,quyen lc chnh phu nam trong tay mot tram ngi; chiliarchy: thienau che, quyen lc nam trong tay mot ngan ngi; myriarchy: van auche, quyen lc nam trong tay mot van ng..
Ben canh nhng t ch nhng the che chnh tr khac nhau so lngngi lanh ao, tieng Anh con co nhng t bat nguon t tieng Hy Lape ch nhng che o c lanh ao bi cac thanh phan khac nhau trongxa ho Ty du alborcracy: che o do ngi da trang lam chu;angelocracy: che o do thien than lam chu; demonocracy, diabolcracy:che o do ac quy lam chu; heroarchy: che o do cac anh hung lam chu...
Qua nhng t ng nh va neu, ta se thay t "dan chu" c dcht ch "democracy", ngha la ngi dan phai nam quyen lam chuhoac trc tiep hoac gian tiep. Nh vay ngha cua ch "dan chu"rat ro rang va minh bach. Moi hnh thc muon thay the quyen lamchu cua dan bang mot ngi hay nhieu ngi, bang mot chnh ang haynhieu chnh ang ma khong thc s cho ngi dan c quyen bo phieuchon la, eu khong the goi la mot che o dan chu di bat c hnhthc nao cho du co dnh vao hai ch "dan chu" nhng a conhoang nh "phap tr, nhat nguyen, tam nguyen, t nguyen, anguyen..."
Noi cach khac, neu nhom Thong Luan a goi che o cong sanoc tai chuyen che tai Viet Nam hien nay la "dan chu nhat nguyen"th khai niem tng ng vi cai goi la "dan chu a nguyen" cuaThong Luan phai la "a au che" (multiocracy) ch khongthe nao co ch "dan chu" (democracy) trong o.
S thc, toi thay viec Thong Luan dan cho che o CSVN cai nhan hieu"dan chu", du dan chu nhat nguyen, nh nguyen, tam nguyen,a nguyen hay g g nguyen i na, cung la mot viec lam ang xau ho vno phan boi vong linh hang trieu ngi a b cong san VN bach haisuot thi gian hn na the ky qua Viec lam o con bat tr v thiiem bay gi ca the gii, trong o co ca nhng ngi cong san caocap, cung eu tha nhan che o cong san la che o phi dan chu.
Neu so sanh vi cac che o oc tai chuyen che cua lch s thegii t xa en nay, toi thay dung t "oc tai chuyen che" egoi che o cong san VN van cha lot ta het s tan nhan, oc ac cua homa phai dung en t demonocracy, ngha la che o cua ac quy th miung ngha, ch lam sao co the nh nhom Thong Luan, nham mat, bnhtai, bt mui khen thm ma goi che o cua CSVN la "dan chu nhatnguyen" cho c?
Khi nhom Thong Luan goi che o cong san la "dan chu nhatnguyen" ta thay ro ay la mot viec lam mau thuan, cng t oat lynham ve van ca cong san lan nhng ngi Viet ngay th nhe da tai haingoa Lam viec nay, nhom Thong Luan muon moi ngi coi che o congsan VN cung la mot che o dan chu, nhng v la "dan chu nhatnguyen" do cong san oc quyen lanh ao nen phai c thay the bangcai goi la "dan chu a nguyen" do Thong Luan nan ra
Khi e hoang t "dan chu a nguyen" nhom Thong Luan a ao tngva thu oan hy vong, neu cong san VN phai chon la gia hai giaiphap, mot la mat tat ca khi the che dan chu c thanh lap; va hai lachap nhan chuyen hoa t "dan chu nhat nguyen" hien nay sang"dan chu a nguyen" e cong san van la nguyen to quan trongtrong ba bon nguyen to cua tan che o, chac chan cong san se chongiai phap hai cua Thong Luan.
Cung cung mot ao tng va thu oan tng t, nhom Thong Luan chorang, neu ngi Viet yeu t do trong nc cung nh hai ngoai phaila chon gia hai giai phap, mot la phai chap nhan tnh the cong sanVN tiep tuc duy tr che o oc tai chuyen che hien nay; va hai lachap nhan nhan nhng vi cong san theo tinh than hoa hp hoa giai eco c mot che o "dan chu a nguyen", chac chan se co nhieungi chon giai phap hai cua Thong Luan.
Nh vay, qua man ao thuat lon song ch ngha, ong Kieng va nhomThong Luan se rung ui vo tay tr thanh v "cu tinh" cua ca ha
Nhng o ch la ao tng. Thc te, cong san co ca tram mu ma, chcquy e li dung ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan. Thc te, ong ao ngiViet hai ngoai eu thay ro ao tng ngay ngo va thu oan tr tra cuaong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan. V vay nhieu ngi a sang suot chorang loi lap "dan chu a nguyen la dan chu" cua ong Kieng vanhom Thong Luan cung het nh loi noi, "Viet Cong la ngi Vietnhng khong phai ngi Viet nao cung la Viet Cong".
Chac chan khi oc cau tren, ta se thay ngi Viet va Viet Congoi choi nhau, tng phan nhau nh nc vi la S oi choi nay cungtng t nh s oi choi gia dan chu va dan chu a nguyen. Va neunh ai ai trong chung ta cung muon lam ngi Viet ma khong muon lamViet Cong th toi tin chac tat ca nhng ai a thch song dan chu euchang dai g om lay cai goi la "dan chu a nguyen" cua ongKieng va nhom Thong Luan.
S LONG NG SNH T VA NGON NG KHONG KHIEM TON CUA NHOM THONG LUAN
* * Long ng snh t: oc li gii thieu cua nhom Thong Luantoi thay ho a dung nhng ch qua ao to bua ln, nang ve trnh diencua nhng ngi long ng snh t ch khong phai la nhng t ng thehien s chn chan, chng mc can phai co cua nhng ngi lam chnhtr.
Mi quy v cung thng thc li gii thieu phung mang trn mat entc ci cua Thong Luan danh cho ban "D an":
"Mot d an chnh tr toan bo cho Viet Nam trc ngng ca cua the ky21 va thien nien ky th ba, bao gom mot so nhan nh ve Viet Namtrong boi canh the gii, mot chu thuyet dng nc, mot d an to chcxa hoi, mot e ngh che o chnh tr, mot chien lc au tranh chodan chu, mot chnh sach chuyen tiep ve dan chu; Mot tai lieu hoctap; Mot tuyen ngon dan chu; Mot thong iep hy vong".
Thu thc, khi oc nhng cau van tren toi giat mnh co cam tng nhang ngoi Viet Nam oc li gii thieu mot ngh quyet chnh tr haycng lnh cua ang cong san th ung hn la oc li gii thieu mottap tai lieu chnh tr cua ngi Viet hai ngoa
Phai chang may ong t nhan la tr thc trong nhom Thong Luan cho rangc nhet tat ca nhng t that nang ky, that tru tng nh "d an,ngng ca, the ky, thien nien ky, boi canh, chu thuyet, chien lc,chnh sach" vo trong mot vai cau gii thieu la u lam ngi ocnoi da ga, dng toc gay phai voi va kiem bang c ban "D an"ve goi au ging hoc thuoc long?
Neu vay th qua la lam v ong ao oc gia thi nay a chan ngay vibenh long ng snh t giong het Thong Luan cua nhng ngi cong san.Suot may chuc nam qua, ngi Viet Nam trong nc cung nh hai ngoaichang la g nhng t that keu ma noi dung rong tuyech, tham ch traingc, c nhng ngi cong san reu rao toi ngay nh "nh caotr tue, the gii ai ong, lanh tu v ai, t tng bach chien bachthang, chien tranh than thanh..."
Kinh nghiem o cong vi s trng thanh ve trnh o chnh tr vakha nang nhan xet tinh te cua ong ao ong bao, toi ngh li giithieu thieu chn chan cua Thong Luan a vo hnh chung tao cho ong aongi oc an tng oc mot oan quang cao ngh quyet ang cong santren bao Nhan Dan th ung hn.
* * Khong khiem ton: Thong Luan la mot trong so hang tram tochc chnh tr cua ngi Viet tai hai ngoa Con ong Nguyen Gia Kiength theo ai VNCR nam nay 53 tuoi, tng lam chu tch sinh vien, aubang ky s cong nghiep, ve nc lam chuyen vien ngan hang, phu ta tongtrng kinh te, day kinh te tai ai hoc Minh c va hien la chutch mot cong ty tin hoc tai Paris. Vi qua kh o, du ong Kieng cotai nang loi lac va du Thong Luan co la to chc quy tu "hang tramtr thc", thiet tng ong va to chc Thong Luan cung khong nendung nhng t ng ay ve "khuon vang thc ngoc" nh "Mottai lieu hoc tap, Mot tuyen ngon dan chu, Mot thong iep hy vong".
Co may ly do khien toi ngh nh va
* Th nhat, tren phng dien tam ly, loi dung t ng nh vay khongkhiem ton, khong ac nhan tam. Xa nay, ngi lam chnh tr ongphng cung nh tay phng eu ong y khiem ton la c tnh tienquyet. Muon c ngi theo mnh, trc het phai lam cho ngi tinmnh, phuc mnh. Muon c ngi tin mnh, phai lam cho ngi hieumnh. Muon c ngi hieu mnh, phai lam cho ngi thch lang ngheieu mnh noi, thch oc ieu mnh viet. Va muon c ngi thchnghe ieu mnh noi, thch oc ieu mnh viet th mnh phai khiem ton,nha nhan trong x the, trong hanh van, trong li no ang nay, thienha cha biet ro ong Kieng la ai ma ong a voi "cat tieng gay dongdac" cho rang mat tri moc la nh tieng gay cua ong th lam saoong co the thu phuc nhan tam e lam nhng chuyen lap bien va tric?
a vay, trong ban "D an" ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luancon "mm moi mm li" tuyen bo mot cau rat rung rn: "Dan chu anguyen khong nhng la chon la hien nhien cho Viet Nam ma con lahng i tat yeu cho loai ngi tien bo". Chu choa! Lay Chua! LayPhat! oc en o toi giat mnh, tng nh ang nghe may tay phngtuong cong san ho het...
Ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan nen biet, ngay ca khi cong bonhng kiet tac chnh tr nh Social Contract cua Jean JacquesRousseau, mmmTuyen Ngon Nhan Quyen dcua Lien Hiep Quoc, mmmTuyen Ngon ocLap dcua My do Thomas Jefferson soan thao.. cung cha co ai dung ennhng t ng ghe gm nh va Hay ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luancho rang ban "D an" cua ong con gia tr gap boi so vi nhngdanh tac chnh tr tren the gii nen ong co quyen dung nhng t ngho phong, hoan vu e "hu" nhng ngi nhe da, ca tin? Neu vayth qua thc la lam v nhng ngi Viet bnh thng hien nay au code g chap nhan theo chan nhng ngi kieu cang lo bch nh ong chodu ong co tai ba nh con kh Ton Ngo Khong chang na
* Th hai, tren phng dien dan chu, loi dung t ng nh ong Kiengva nhom Thong Luan a mang mau sac "phi dan chu" cua nhngngi vo ngc t nhan "duy nga oc ton". Nhat la cau, "Mottai lieu hoc tap", thiet tng ch thch hp cho noi bo Thong Luanhoac nhng to chc ong quan iem vi Thong Luan, con oi vi cac tochc chnh tr khong ong quan iem th cau o a mang mau sac"cng che, ap at" hn la "thuyet phuc, chia se, mi goi,tham khao". Nh vay, xem ra ngay t thoat khi, ong Kieng va nhomThong Luan a t mau thuan khi vo tnh e lo y nh dung "nam codan chu a nguyen" e nh thien ha, ai muon lam "mot nguyen" trongchnh phu th chu kho a co e ong choang chiec thong long "phidan chu" buoc co lai roi loi i theo con ng cua ong, mangtai lieu ong soan ve hoc nh hoc trc tac cua lanh tu...
D nhien, chieu phap "dan chu gia hieu" nay cua ong chang cog mi me v t t ngan xa en nay, rat nhieu bao chua trong o cocong san, nhat la cong san Viet Nam, a say sa x dung no e m danva an ap dan.
Chac ong Kieng cung phai ong y, nhan tai ngi Viet tai hai ngoairat nhieu Trong so o, nhng ngi co tam huyet cung rat ong. Vthe, mot ngi du tai ba, uy tn, co cong lao vi dan vi nc may ina, khi cong bo quan iem lap trng cua mnh cung khong the voi vadan cho no cai nhan hieu "mot tai lieu hoc tap, mot tuyen ngondan chu, mot thong iep hy vong, mot hng i tat yeu cua loai ngitien bo".
Cho du Thong Luan a quy tu c "hang tram tr thc" cong vithi gian "hn mot nam nghien cu trao oi va uc ket", toithiet ngh ieu o cung khong the la yeu to ghe gm e voi va t chotai lieu cua mnh la "mot tuyen ngon dan chu, mot thong iep hyvong, mot tai lieu hoc tap" cho ca bay, tam chuc trieu ngi VietNam trong o co hang trieu tr thc, nhan s luon luon quan tam en atnc, dan toc suot thi gian may chuc nam qua D nhien, ong Kieng laicang khong the ngay ngo, ech ngoi ay gieng coi tri bang vung khiphnh bung oi lam con bo, muon ca nam, sau ty ngi tren the gii coi"D an" cua ong la "hng i tat yeu cua loai ngi tien bo".
* Th ba, tren phng dien ngon ng, toi kho co the tng tng mottap tai lieu dai ca tram trang cua ong Kieng lai co the phan than etr thanh ca chuc th nh "mot d an chnh tr, mot tai lieu hoctap, mot tuyen ngon dan chu, mot thong iep hy vong, mot chien lcau tranh, mot chnh sach chuyen tiep, mot e ngh che o chnhtr..." Cha le ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan cho rang c nhet batat ca nhng t ao to but ln o vo trong ban "D an" la ongco quyen coi ban "D an" co u cac gia tr ghe gm o hay saoVa neu nh ong Kieng coi ban "D an" dai ngot 100 trang cua ongla mot ban "Tuyen ngon dan chu" th toi tin rang trong lch scua nhng ban tuyen ngon thanh van tren the gii ke t khi nhan loaico ch viet en nay, cha co ban tuyen ngon nao dai nh ban"Tuyen ngon dan chu" cua ong Kieng.
Thu thc, khi oc li gii thieu cua nhom Thong Luan toi t hoi, phaichang ong Kieng va to chc Thong Luan cho rang khi mot nhom ngi menh danhla tr thc ngoi lai "nghien cu, trao oi va uc ket" suotmot nam tri e viet mot cai g dai ca tram trang giay di nhan hieu"D an chnh tr dan chu a nguyen" th ho co quyen coi no trthanh mot mon sup thap cam va "tuyen ngon dan chu" va"tai lieu hoc tap" va "thong iep hy vong" va "chuthuyet, chien lc, chnh sach" ham ba lang?
Viet en ay toi lai nh cach ay khoang mot tuan, khi oc mot soth tren Internet, tnh c c biet, ngoai nhng t ng nh aang tai, luc au ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan con t phong cho "Dan chnh tr a nguyen" them mot lo t rat keu nh "Mottuyen ngon nhan quyen, Mot tuyen ngon dan quyen, Mot tuyen ngon oclap, Mot mac khai hoa bnh, Mot khuc khai hoan ca chnh tr, Mot litien tri cua thi ai, Mot tuyen ngon tam giao ong nguyen, Mot vienanh vang son cua Viet Nam the gii ai ong, Mot bc ngoat quan trongcua lch 5000 nghn nam van hien". Sau khong hieu v ly do g,nhng t ng nay khong c dung t Tiec that!
Chuyen o tuy khong biet thc h ra sao nhng ch nhn vao nhng tng ong Kieng va nhom Thong Luan a dung toi thay cung qua u e cothe ket luan: Benh long ng snh t cua ong va nhom Thong Luan a vohnh chung lam cho long ngi oc nguoi lanh va th vi ban "Dan" cho du ho cha he oc, cha he tha
NHNG LI NHAN XET CUA CAC V KHOA BANG C THONG LUAN VIEN DAN
Trong phan gii thieu ban "D an", Thong Luan co vien dan linhan xet cua mot so v tieng tam trong cong ong ngi Viet hai ngoaTrong so o co tien s, giao s, chnh tr gia, luat gia, nha van,nha bao..
Sau khi oc nhng dong cam ngh cua cac v, toi ban khoan khong bietnhng v nay co phai la ngi cua nhom Thong Luan hay khong ma saophan ong eu giong Thong Luan benh long ng snh t. Sau ay lamot vai th du.
* Ong Nguyen Huy Bao, cu khoa trng ai hoc Van Khoa Sai Gonnhan xet: "Mot tuyet tac ve the loai ngh luan, van phong citran e boc lo y". Khong hieu "van phong ci tran"la loai van phong the nao nh? Co phai la thoat y 50% khong?Neu vay "van phong c.. 100%" chac tuyet tac hn chang??
* Ong Ton That Thien, tien s kinh te, giao s ai hoc, cu Botrng Thong Tin: "Mot tac pham chnh tr hoc thng hang, mottac pham van chng tuyet my". Ong nay snh t qua hoa anh matca long t trong! C nh li ong nay th ong Kieng va nhomThong Luan phai c ca giai Nobel Hoa Bnh lan Nobel Van Chngtrong nam na Ta th ch xem the nao..
* Cu ai ta cong san Bui Tn: "Trach nhiem, t tin, y thcsau sac oi vi thi cuoc, vi dan, vi nc. Mot phng an cu ncgon, xuc tch, tam huyet va tr tue". Ong cu ai ta cong sannay tuy xuat hien hai ngoai khong lau nhng noi nh noi am loinoi long ng, snh t sac mui cong san. Ong nay cung con la ngico thoi quen vo ngc t nhan mnh la "s phu cua thi ai" macdu ong theo cong san ca na the ky, trc tiep gian tiep nhung tay vaokhong biet bao nhieu toi ac, luc nao cung nh con vet toi ngay hot catang boc cong san va co gang lam tron chc vu boi but goc tren baoNhan Dan bang cach viet bai xui duc thanh nien Mien Bac "len nggiai phong Mien Nam".
* Vo Nhan Tr, tien s kinh te, ang vien cong san ly khai nhan xet:"Neu phai cham iem e so sanh th toi cho D an Chnh tr Danchu a Nguyen 18,5 tren 20, Bao cao Chnh tr cua ang cong san VietNam zero". Ong tien s cong san nay tuy ly khai cong san nhngchang hieu v muon che dieu ban "D an" hay v "mau congsan" van con soi trong huyet quan hay sao ma bong dng co loi sosanh ky cuc qua xa lam ngi oc tng "D an" va ban tay oMi ch cach nhau co 18 phan ri! Khong biet ong Kieng va nhomThong Luan ngh sao ch ong tien s kinh te nay co cho toi 100 iemtren 100 con cho quy o cong san zero tren 100 toi cung cho la ongnay xo xien muon a gio lai mnh.
oc nhng li nhan xet c Thong Luan vien dan toi ong y moi ngieu co quyen a ra nhng li khen che cua mnh cung nh toi coquyen trnh bay nhng suy ngh trc nhng li khen che o. Nhng xanay khen che co nam bay ng. Co li che a mnh t cho toi en chosang th cung co li khen ay mnh xuong ho luc nao khong biet. Vvay, viec chon la nhng li khen che danh cho mnh roi ang bao lachuyen rat quan trong v qua o, ngi oc se en vi mnh hoac lanhxa mnh.
Thu thc, trong so 10 nhan xet cua mi v khoa bang toi ch thay nhanxet cua ong Vo Long Trieu, cu Bo trng va Dan bieu VNCH la chngmc, ung an va ang knh. Li nhan xet cua ong Trieu nh sau:"oc Th thach & Hy vong, nhng ngi ang u t ve van mang atnc co the so sanh, bo sung hoac m rong kien thc chnh tr cuamnh".
(Con tiep...)